Improved Joining of Metal Components to Composite Structures
- Created on Thursday, 01 January 2009
Uncured composite material is intertwined with metal studs, then cured.
Systems requirements for complex spacecraft drive design requirements that lead to structures, components, and/or enclosures of a multi-material and multifunctional design. The varying physical properties of aluminum, tungsten, Invar, or other high-grade aerospace metals when utilized in conjunction with lightweight composites multiply system level solutions. These multi-material designs are largely dependent upon effective joining techniques, which create a “monolithic,” well-integrated and seamlessly functional structure.
An improved method of joining metal components to matrix/fiber composite-material structures has been invented. The method is particularly applicable to equipping such thin-wall polymer-matrix composite (PMC) structures as tanks with flanges, ceramic matrix composite (CMC) liners for high heat engine nozzles, and other metallic-to- composite attachments. The method is oriented toward new architectures and distributing mechanical loads as widely as possible in the vicinities of attachment locations to prevent excessive concentrations of stresses that could give rise to delaminations, debonds, leaks, and other failures.
The method in its most basic form can be summarized as follows: A metal component is to be joined to a designated attachment area on a composite-material structure. In preparation for joining, the metal component is fabricated to include multiple “studs” projecting from the aforementioned face. Also in preparation for joining, holes just wide enough to accept the studs are molded into, drilled, or otherwise formed in the corresponding locations in the designated attachment area of the uncured (“wet”) composite structure. The metal component is brought together with the uncured composite structure so that the studs become firmly seated in the holes, thereby causing the composite material to become intertwined with the metal component in the joining area. Alternately, it is proposed to utilize other mechanical attachment schemes whereby the uncured composite and metallic parts are joined with “z-direction” fasteners. The resulting “wet” assembly is then subjected to the composite-curing heat treatment, becoming a unitary structure. It should be noted that this new art will require different techniques for CMC’s versus PMC’s, but the final architecture and companion curing philosophy is the same. For instance, a chemical vapor infiltration (CVI) fabrication technique may require special integration of the pre-form and metallic part, as well as, high-temperature metals or transitional molten metals to achieve the desired architecture.
The method accommodates numerous variations. For example, in a demonstration of the method, an aluminum plate having dimensions of 4 by 3 by 0.50 in. (about 10.2 by 7.6 by 1.3 cm) was joined with a 2-by-8-by-0.25-in. (about 5.1-by-20.3-by-0.6-cm) plate made of composite of carbon fibers in an epoxy (thermoset) matrix toughened with a thermoplastic material. The composite plate was prepared in uncured form, and 16 holes were predrilled in the aluminum plate to accept thread-tapping screws intended to serve as substitutes for studs. The array of these holes was used as a template to drill 16 corresponding holes in the uncured composite plate. The screws were inserted through the holes in the uncured composite plate and tightened into the holes in the aluminum plate (see upper part of figure). The resulting assembly was placed in an autoclave, where it was heated to a temperature of 350 °F (≈177 °C) to cure the epoxy. Then the assembly was cooled very slowly [between 10 and 15 °F (between about 5.6 and 8.3 °C) per hour] so that the difference between the coefficients of thermal expansion of the aluminum and the composite would not induce excessive stress.
The resulting unitary structure was subjected to a tensile/bending test as shown in the lower part of the figure. When the test was terminated at a load of 4,683 lb (≈20.8 kN), the composite panel was bent significantly, but no sign of failure of the joint was visible. [The screws were rated to withstand a load of 10,240 lb (≈45.5 kN).]
This work was done by Edmund Semmes of Marshall Space Flight Center.