Please Login at the top
of the page to download.
There has been ongoing debate as to whether or not a hydraulic force machine that applies the force simultaneously to both the reference standard and the unit under test is more repeatable and reproducible when the force is applied and transferred with 3 bars versus 2 bars. The debate centers around alignment of the reference standard and the unit under test. There is no disagreement about the benefits of using a triangular configuration when using multiple load cells to weigh an object; however, there is a debate over any advantages that might be offered by using a 3 bar Universal Calibrating Machine (UCM) instead of a traditional 2 bar system. This paper provides test results for repeatability and reproducibility for a 2 bar UCM and a 3 bar UCM, showing the null hypothesis to be correct and proving that there is not a difference between either type of UCM.