Battery Power Source Options for Mission-Critical Applications
Jun 30 2007
Page 2 of 3
advertisement:
Lead Acid
Lead acid is a tried and true rechargeable
power system, providing a costeffective
and readily available solution.
Despite its lower energy density, lead
acid often is utilized in critical applications
where size and weight is not an
issue, such as oceanographic surveying
devices and military vehicle applications.
Lead acid batteries operate most efficiently
at moderate temperatures so
deployments in cold or deep ocean environments
or where extended exposure
to elevated temperatures can be expected
may result in reduced capability.
Lead acid batteries are moderately
robust to shock and vibration induced by
ocean’s waves; however, the system eventually
can yield to continuous pounding.
The environmental impact of lead acid
also must be considered – it is highly
toxic and remains so forever after the battery
is used. Lead acid batteries must be
recycled and all of the materials tightly
controlled for health and environmental
reasons, so a mission-critical device utilizing
lead acid batteries must be positioned
in an ultimately retrievable location.
Lithium-Ion
Rechargeable Li-ion battery packs are ideal for small, portable applications in environments with less harsh temperatures
Lithium-ion (Li-ion) is a popular
rechargeable system that performs well
in many critical applications due to its
light weight, high energy density, and
long cycle life as compared to other
rechargeable batteries (potentially double
the cycle life as compared to lead
acid). It is quickly becoming the battery
of choice in many small, portable applications,
supported by its high availability
driven by the consumer segment. Liion
is available in a limited number of
form factors and is not particularly
durable in terms of withstanding
extraordinary shock and vibration,
making it more suitable for applications
where shock and vibration conditions
are relatively benign. Small handheld
devices with ready access to
recharging systems are particularly well
suited to this chemistry.
Li-ion’s limited upper temperature
range also restricts use in certain
extreme environment applications, such
as downhole drilling and aerospace
devices. This system is, however, the
fastest growing of all rechargeables in
both the consumer and commercial segment,
and as such will see continued
improvements in terms of performance
envelope and safety, with increased
adoption in a variety of applications.
Alkaline Cells
The well-known alkaline battery can be a suitable choice in mission-critical activities despite its low energy density.
Of available primary battery types, the
familiar alkaline cell is the most popular.
Its lower cost, availability, long shelf life,
and low internal resistance make it a fit
for many mission-critical activities, particularly
those with unpredictable mission
schedules - alkaline batteries will
hold up to 80% of charge for several
years if stored in standard warehouse
conditions. Alkaline cells also are easy to
transport and do not require hazardous
material certifications for shipment.
Alkaline’s relatively low energy density,
however, must be taken into consideration
when designing a battery. In applications
where space, weight, and
replacement schedule are not critical,
alkaline cells offer a reliable, low-cost
solution for primary battery power.
Dedicated to helping you design better products in a digital world... your guide to the latest tools & techniques for digital prototyping, simulation, and analysis of the real-world performance of your ideas.