Light of different colors travels at different speeds in different materials and structures. This is why we see white light split into its constituent colors after refracting through a prism, a phenomenon called dispersion. An ordinary lens cannot focus light of different colors to a single spot due to this dispersion. This means different colors are never in focus at the same time, and so an image formed by such a simple lens is inevitably blurred. Conventional imaging systems solve this problem by stacking multiple lenses, but this solution comes at the cost of increased complexity and weight.

Top panels: Scanning electron micrographs of sections of broadband meta-lenses. They are composed of silicon nanopillars with various cross-sectional shapes patterned on a glass substrate. Bottom panel: Photo showing two elements of a multi-element meta-lens imaging. (Image courtesy of Sajan Shrestha, Adam Overvig, Nanfang Yu/Columbia Engineering)

Columbia Engineering researchers have created the first flat lens capable of correctly focusing a large range of colors of any polarization to the same focal spot without the need for any additional elements. Only a micron thick, their revolutionary flat lens is much thinner than a sheet of paper and offers performance comparable to top-of-the-line compound lens systems.

A conventional lens works by routing all the light falling upon it through different paths so that the whole light wave arrives at the focal point at the same time. It is manufactured to do so by adding an increasing amount of delay to the light as it goes from the edge to the center of the lens. This is why a conventional lens is thicker at its center than at its edge.

With the goal of inventing a thinner, lighter, and cheaper lens, the team took a different approach. Using their expertise in optical “metasurfaces,” — engineered two-dimensional structures — to control light propagation in free space, the researchers built flat lenses made of pixels, or “meta-atoms.” Each meta-atom has a size that is just a fraction of the wavelength of light and delays the light passing through it by a different amount. By patterning a very thin flat layer of nanostructures on a substrate as thin as a human hair, the researchers were able to achieve the same function as a much thicker and heavier conventional lens system. Looking to the future, they anticipate that the meta-lenses could replace bulky lens systems, comparable to the way flat-screen TVs have replaced cathode-ray-tube TVs.

By using meta-atoms of complex shapes, the lens not only provides the correct distribution of delay for a single color, but also for a continuous spectrum of light. And because they are so thin, they have the potential to drastically reduce the size and weight of any optical instrument or device used for imaging, such as cameras, microscopes, telescopes, and even eyeglasses.

The team fabricated the meta-lenses using standard 2D planar fabrication techniques similar to those used for fabricating computer chips. They say the process of mass manufacturing meta-lenses should even be a good deal simpler than producing computer chips, as they need to define just one layer of nanostructures. In comparison, modern computer chips need numerous layers, some as many as 100. Another advantage of flat meta-lenses is that, unlike conventional lenses, they do not need to go through costly and time-consuming grinding and polishing processes. The lens designs can be sent to semiconductor foundries for mass production and benefit from the economies of scale inherent in the industry.

Because the flat lens can focus light with wavelengths ranging from 1.2 to 1.7 microns in the near-infrared to the same focal spot, it can form color images in the near-infrared band because all of the colors are in focus at the same time — essential for color photography. The lens can also focus light of any arbitrary polarization state, so that it works not only in a lab setting, where the polarization can be well controlled, but also in real world applications, where ambient light has random polarization. It also works for transmitted light, convenient for integration into an optical system.

According to the designers, their design algorithm exhausts all degrees of freedom in sculpting an interface into a binary pattern, and as a result, the lenses are able to reach performance approaching the theoretic limit that a single nanostructured interface can possibly achieve. They demonstrated a few flat lenses with the best theoretically possible combined traits: for a given meta-lens diameter, they achieved the tightest focal spot over the largest wavelength range.

Now that the meta-lenses are approaching the performance of high-quality imaging lens sets, with much smaller weight and size, the team has the challenge of improving the lenses’ efficiency. The flat lenses currently are not optimal because a small fraction of the incident optical power is either reflected by the lens or scattered into unwanted directions. They are optimistic that the issue of efficiency is not fundamental and are working to address the problem. They are also in talks with industry on further developing and licensing the technology.

For more information, contact Holly Evarts at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it., 212-854-3206.

Photonics & Imaging Technology Magazine

This article first appeared in the January, 2019 issue of Photonics & Imaging Technology Magazine.

Read more articles from this issue here.

Read more articles from the archives here.