With an X-ray experiment at the European Synchrotron ESRF in Grenoble, France, Empa researchers were able to demonstrate how well their real-time acoustic monitoring of laser weld seams works. With almost 90 percent reliability, they detected the formation of unwanted pores that impair the quality of weld seams. Thanks to a special evaluation method based on artificial intelligence (AI), the detection process is completed in just 70 milliseconds.

Laser welding is a process suitable for joining metals and thermoplastics. It has become particularly well established in highly automated production, for example in the automotive industry, because a laser operates with virtually no wear, is very fast, and offers high precision. But until now, the quality of a weld seam could only be documented retrospectively, either by means of X-rays, magnetic analysis methods, or by dissecting individual samples from production. Realtime monitoring of the weld quality would be a major advantage.

While in conduction welding only the surface of the material is molten, in deep penetration welding the laser beam penetrates quickly and deeply into the material and produces a thin hole filled with metal and gas vapors, which is called a “keyhole”. If the keyhole becomes too deep, the vapor pressure of the metal vapor decreases while the surface tension of the molten metal increases. The keyhole becomes unstable and can eventually collapse, leaving a pore in the weld seam — an unwanted fault in the material. It is therefore important for the quality of laser welding seams, to be able detect the moment when the keyhole becomes unstable. Before now, it was only possible to look into the keyhole from the top using optical methods.

A group of Empa researchers has now succeeded in precisely detecting and documenting the moment of instability in deep penetration laser welding. To do this, they are using an inexpensive acoustic sensor while also measuring the reflection of the laser beam on the metal surface. The combined data are analyzed within 70 milliseconds with the help of artificial intelligence (convolutional neural network). This allows the quality of the laser welding process to be monitored in real time.

The Empa researchers recently demonstrated the accuracy of their monitoring method at the European Synchrotron ESRF in Grenoble. Using their laser, they melted a keyhole into a small aluminum plate, which was simultaneously scanned by hard X-ray radiation. The entire process, which takes less than a hundredth of a second, was recorded with a high-speed X-ray camera. The result: the individual phases of the welding process could be correctly identified with more than 90 percent certainty.

Once the laser beam hits the metal, the first phase of the heat conduction welding process begins — only the surface is melted. Subsequently, a stable keyhole is formed, which “wobbles” (unstable keyhole) with longer exposure times. Sometimes the keyhole spits out liquid metal, similar to a volcanic eruption (blowout). If it collapses in an uncontrolled manner, a pore is formed. All these phases can be detected in real time.

In some experiments, the researchers created pores in the weld seam and then closed them again with a second laser pulse. The formation of the pore could be detected with 87 percent certainty, successful removal with as much as 73 percent. Being able to detect the fault during the welding means that post-processing with the laser can be started immediately.

The monitoring process developed at Empa can be used not only for laser welding, but also for quality control of 3D-printed metal parts. In the powder bed process — one of the most common methods used in 3D metal printing — a laser beam passes through a layer of metal beads and welds them together. If pores appear, the laser could be directed towards the defective area a second time to remove each pore subsequently. However, this can only be done with the help of real-time monitoring, because any pores that have been created must be eliminated immediately, before they are covered by further layers of metal.

“One advantage of our monitoring method is that the acoustic and optical sensors we use are inexpensive and robust and can be easily retrofitted in existing industrial plants,” said Kilian Wasmer, who coordinated the work. The AI that was used for the signal processing was done with graphics processors that can calculate several tasks in parallel. “Such processors are also used in modern game consoles and are available at a reasonable price. Thus, the rapid technical progress in Playstation and others has helped our work a lot.”

For more information, contact Rainer Klose at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


Sensor Technology Magazine

This article first appeared in the September, 2020 issue of Sensor Technology Magazine.

Read more articles from the archives here.